Earnings Season: Hold or Sell? I Choose a Third Option: Hold, Watch, and Be Ready
Earnings night always brings the same temptation.
Should I sell before the numbers come out, or hold and hope for a big jump tomorrow morning?
Hold or Sell?
Personally, I think that is the wrong question.
My approach is usually HOLD, especially when I own a company because I believe in its long-term growth. But holding does not mean doing nothing. Before earnings, I ask myself one important question:
If the stock drops 10% tomorrow morning, would I still want to own the company?
If my answer is yes, I am normally comfortable holding through earnings.
🟢 Why I Usually Hold Through Earnings
For quality companies, particularly in technology, AI and semiconductors, I don't want one quarter to determine my entire investment decision.
Companies like $NVIDIA(NVDA)$ are not just stories about whether EPS beats expectations by a few cents. What matters more to me is whether the long-term business thesis remains intact.
I would rather look at questions such as:
-
Is revenue still growing at a healthy rate?
-
Are margins and free cash flow holding up?
-
Is management's forward guidance still strong?
-
Is demand for the company's products sustainable?
-
Is the competitive advantage strengthening or weakening?
-
Most importantly, does the valuation still make sense relative to future growth?
A stock can beat earnings and still fall because expectations were simply too high. Likewise, a company can miss one quarter and still remain an excellent long-term investment.
Price reaction and business performance are not always the same thing.
📉 A 10% Drop Doesn't Automatically Mean “Buy the Dip”
This is probably the biggest lesson I have learned from investing.
I like market corrections because they can create opportunities. But I don't believe every red candle is automatically a bargain.
Imagine a stock I own falls 10% after earnings.
My first reaction would not be:
“Great! Buy more!”
Instead, I would ask:
“Why did it drop?”
If the company continues to deliver strong growth, healthy cash flow and solid guidance, but investors sell because expectations were too optimistic, I may see that weakness as an opportunity to accumulate gradually.
But if the drop comes from deteriorating fundamentals, slowing demand, weaker margins or a structural change in the company's competitive position, averaging down just because the share price is cheaper can be dangerous.
I buy dips in price, not dips in business quality.
That distinction is extremely important to me.
🟡 Why I Keep Some Cash Before Earnings
Although I normally hold, I also don't like being 100% invested before a major earnings event.
Cash gives me optionality.
If the stock jumps 10%, great. My existing position benefits.
If it falls 10% while the investment thesis remains intact, I have capital available to add.
And if the results reveal something fundamentally wrong with my original thesis, I don't have to buy anything at all.
This takes some pressure away from predicting the immediate market reaction.
Instead of asking:
“Will the stock rise or fall tomorrow?”
I can ask:
“What will I do under each scenario?”
That is a question I can actually control.
🎢 The Most Dangerous Part of Earnings Night Is Emotion
To me, earnings season is also a test of psychology.
When a stock surges after hours, FOMO tells us we should have bought more.
When it crashes, fear tells us to sell immediately.
Neither emotion necessarily tells us anything about what the company is worth.
This is why I prefer to have a plan before the earnings release. If my investment thesis is based on several years of business growth, I shouldn't allow one evening of volatility to completely change it.
Of course, holding long term doesn't mean holding blindly.
If earnings reveal that the reasons I bought the company are no longer valid, I am perfectly willing to reconsider the position.
Long-term investing requires patience, but it also requires the willingness to admit when the facts have changed.
🎯 So, Hold, Sell or Wait?
My choice is:
🟢 HOLD, but keep some ammunition ready.
For companies I genuinely believe in, I don't normally sell simply because earnings are coming.
At the same time, I won't rush to buy before the announcement just because I am afraid of missing a rally.
I prefer to let the company report, study what has actually changed, and take advantage of volatility when the market gives me a good opportunity.
If the stock rises, I already own it.
If it falls but the fundamentals remain strong, I can accumulate gradually.
If the business thesis breaks, I reassess instead of blindly buying the dip.
Earnings night isn't about predicting tomorrow's share price. It's about knowing what you own, why you own it, and what would make you change your mind.
That's the approach that helps me sleep better when earnings are tonight. 😴📈
💬 What about you?
If one of your largest holdings were reporting tonight and you knew the stock could move ±10% tomorrow, would you:
🟢 Hold and ride through it? 🔴 Trim before the announcement? 🟡 Wait until the numbers are out?
Hold? Wait? Trim?
And the harder question:
If it dropped 10% tomorrow, would you have enough conviction to buy more?
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
- BerniceCarter·11-10 16:34That ±10% framing sounds calm, but NVDA's multiple already prices in a lot more than one clean quarter lolLikeReport
