💥"Pharma Heaven & Hell": MRK & AMGN Lead Dow, LLY Hits ATH, Health Insurance Plunges
[Allin]Hey~Tigers: The pharma sector is currently experiencing a "heaven and hell" divergence.
On one side, $Merck(MRK)$ and $Amgen(AMGN)$ enjoy safe-haven premiums, $Eli Lilly(LLY)$ hits new highs on GLP-1 deal certainty; on the other side, health insurance faces a business model collapse due to Trump's "direct subsidy payment" rhetoric. Investors must watch policy signals closely to avoid walking a tightrope between innovative drug dividends and policy risks.
This article focuses on:
Market Overview: Dow Hits New High, Pharma Sector Emerges
GLP-1 Weight Loss Drug Market Upheaval: Government Price-Cut Deal Impacts Lilly, Novo Nordisk Competitive Landscape
Trump's Comments Trigger Health Insurance Sector "Earthquake"
In a Polarized Market: Focus on Select Stocks and Smart Money Moves
I. Market Overview: Dow Hits New High, Pharma Sector Emerges
$Dow Jones(.DJI)$ Tuesday surged near historic highs, with pharmaceutical giants leading the charge. $Merck(MRK)$ topped Dow components with a 4.8% gain, while $Amgen(AMGN)$ soared 4.6%. The two giants ignited enthusiasm across the healthcare sector.
Leading Stocks Analysis: Fundamental and Technical Resonance
$Merck(MRK)$ 's explosive rally was no accident. Market rumors suggest Keytruda patent strategy achieved key breakthroughs, while early pipeline candidates disclosed positive oncology immunotherapy data. Technically, the stock broke above the 200-day MA at $87, closing above $90. Options markets show heavy call position building, implying institutional investors see upside to the $95 resistance zone.
$Amgen(AMGN)$ was even stronger, with the 4.6% gain pushing it to fresh 52-week highs near the historic peak of $346.8. Mainly benefiting from 37% biosimilar growth in Q3 and a strategic partnership with Lonza to reduce R&D risks. RSI shows ample momentum.
Pharma ETFs like $ProShares Ultra Nasdaq Biotechnology(BIB)$ , $GRI BIO INC(GRI)$ , and $Direxion Daily S&P Biotech Bull 3x Shares(LABU)$ , $Direxion Daily Pharmaceutical & Medical Bull 3X Shares(PILL)$ , $Direxion Daily Healthcare Bull 3X Shares(CURE)$ all rose, showing institutions are piling into this defensive growth sector.
However, extreme divergence emerged: GLP-1 weight loss drugmakers hit new highs on policy tailwinds, while managed care and hospital stocks faced historic selling on Trump healthcare reform rhetoric.
II. GLP-1 Weight Loss Drug Market Upheaval: Government Price-Cut Deal Impacts Lilly, Novo Nordisk Competitive Landscape
While traditional pharma celebrated, global weight loss drug duopolists $Eli Lilly(LLY)$ and $Novo-Nordisk A/S(NVO)$ saw shocking news. $Defiance Daily Target 2X Long NVO ETF(NVOX)$
Per the deal, they agreed to cut GLP-1 weight loss drug (Mounjaro, Wegovy) Medicare prices by 30-40%. Core terms:
Channel | Price (monthly) | Applicable Drugs | Effective Date |
Medicare/Medicaid | $245 | Ozempic/Wegovy/Zepbound | Mid-2026 |
TrumpRx.gov direct sales | $350→$245 | All GLP-1 injectables | Gradual from Jan 2026 |
Oral starter dose | $149 | Orforglipron/Wegovy oral | Immediate upon approval |
Policy Compensation: Drugmakers Receive Massive Benefits, in exchange, both companies received:
Three-year tariff exemption (worth >$5B)
FDA priority review vouchers (cuts new drug review by 6-10 months)
Novo Nordisk's additional $10B US investment
Market Impact:Near-term pressure
$Eli Lilly(LLY)$ Stock jumped 5% on Nov 10 to a record $978. Since late October, continuous gains have pushed it near $1,000. Goldman Sachs maintains a $95B 2030 market forecast, believing "price for volume" will open the 60M Medicare patient market. Lilly's oral orforglipron launches Q2 2026 with first-mover advantage.
$Novo-Nordisk A/S(NVO)$ : Relatively weak, Q3 growth at just 5%, Danish capacity cost pressures. But its semaglutide diabetes moat remains solid. Novo fell 0.8% Tuesday on margin and supply cost concerns.
Long-term certainty strengthened
Competitive barriers reinforced: Deal terms require three-year supply stability guarantees, effectively blocking smaller weight loss drug developers from Medicare and strengthening the duopoly.
III. Trump's Comments Trigger Health Insurance Sector "Earthquake"
In stark contrast to pharma gains, managed care and hospital stocks collapsed.
Timeline: Nov 8-11
Date | Event | Market Impact |
Nov 8 | Trump Truth Social post blasts ACA subsidies, demands "give money directly to people, not insurers" | Market closed |
Nov 10 | Senate passes funding bill without ACA subsidy extension | Health insurers fell pre-market |
Nov 11 | Trump repeats "insurers are parasites," triggers institutional selling | OSCR crashed 17.55%, CNC fell 8.81% |
President Trump continuously attacked ACA subsidy mechanisms on social media and campaign events, calling it "a taxpayer money disaster" and suggesting he'd "completely reform" Medicaid and Medicare Advantage payments if re-elected.
Trump Quote:
"Let's start now—take the hundreds of billions flowing to these 'big bad' blood-sucking insurers and give it directly to the people... End the worst healthcare system in the world, ObamaCare."
This ignited a health insurer selloff:
Stock | Monday Drop | Trigger |
-17.55% | 100% revenue from ACA exchanges; investors fear subsidy cuts will trigger mass cancellations | |
-8.81% | Largest Medicaid operator, >$8B annual subsidy income; any federal payment policy shift hits core model | |
-7.34% | >60% ACA business; worried about patient payment ability and bad debt | |
-3.63% | Hospital stocks dragged by bad debt risks; watch 2026 bad debt rates |
IV. In a Polarized Market: Focus on Select Stocks and Smart Money Moves
Traditional Pharma & Biotech: Safe-haven capital inflow and clear earnings visibility make Merck and Amgen top picks. Low valuations (forward P/E ~13x) and 3%+ dividend yields are attractive for long-term investors.
Emerging Therapies: GLP-1 enters "policy implementation phase." Focus shifts from R&D to commercial execution. Lilly's superior capacity planning and product mix (diabetes + weight loss + Alzheimer's) command valuation premiums, while Novo Nordisk must prove cost control and US localization.
Avoid List: Any company with >40% revenue from ACA, Medicaid, or Medicare Advantage needs caution. OSCR, CNC face valuation trap risks; policy uncertainty will overhang until 2024 election clarifies.
Smart Money Flows in ETFs
Despite volatile individual stocks, $Health Care Select Sector SPDR Fund(XLV)$ and $iShares Biotechnology ETF(IBB)$ saw inflows.
Data shows institutions aren't leaving healthcare but "risk-repricing"—adding patent-protected pharma, cutting policy-sensitive insurers/hospitals, and tactically trading GLP-1 names.
Outlook: Divergence Continues, Watch Three Catalysts
Date | Event | Potential Impact |
Nov 17 | Medicare drug price negotiation list update | May include more GLP-1 drugs |
Nov 28 | Thanksgiving GLP-1 sales data | Tests real demand strength in retail channels |
Dec 5 | Supreme Court ACA hearing | If subsidies ruled unconstitutional, CNC/OSCR could fall another 20%+ |
Jan 2026 | TrumpRx platform launch | Tests direct sales model viability |
Mar 2026 | Congress MMA reform vote | Determines Medicare reimbursement legality |
Risk Warnings:
Execution Risk: TrumpRx platform launch in Jan 2026; tech glitches or supply disruptions could hurt stocks
Legal Risk: GLP-1 Medicare coverage requires congressional reform; deal could collapse if not passed by 2026
Political Risk: If Democrats win 2026 midterms, ACA subsidy mechanisms could be reviewed
ALL in all:
The current pharma rally is essentially a violent repricing of "safe assets" vs. "policy-risk assets."
$Merck(MRK)$ and $Amgen(AMGN)$ 's surge reflects the market chasing certainty premiums, while $Eli Lilly(LLY)$ and $Novo-Nordisk A/S(NVO)$ 's government deals signal innovative drugs shifting from "free pricing" to "value-based pricing."
Meanwhile, Trump's comments create huge uncertainty for 2024 US healthcare policy, forcing a systemic repricing of managed care valuations.
Investors must watch policy signals closely to avoid walking a tightrope between innovative drug dividends and policy risks.
And Tigers, what concept stocks do you own or hold? Or is an index or sector ETF the better choice? What's your strategy?
Welcome to open a CBA today and enjoy access to a trading limit of up to SGD 20,000 with upcoming 0-commission, unlimited trading on SG, HK, and US stocks, as well as ETFs. Find out more here.
Complete your first Cash Boost Account trade with a trade amount of ≥ SGD 5000* to get SGD 688 stock vouchers*! The trade can be executed using any payment type available under the Cash Boost Account: Cash, CPF, SRS, or CDP.
Other helpful links:
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
- LEESIMON·11-14🩷GoodLikeReport
- Anh·11-13Great article, would you like to share it?LikeReport
