Want to Create More Competition in Grocery Delivery? Let DoorDash and Instacart Merge.

Dow Jones00:21

The combined company would be better able to challenge corporate juggernauts like Amazon, Walmart and Uber

The Justice Department should let the DoorDash and Instacart merger go through to avoid giving Amazon, Walmart and other giants an unfair advantage, Kenneth Rapoza writes.

The Department of Justice is reportedly planning to review the proposed $17 billion merger of DoorDash and Instacart in a routine look-through of the deal. But the announcement of the merger last month instantly led the big delivery giants to circle the wagons, raising fears about an ostensible lack of competition for consumers. The reality is that corporate juggernauts like Amazon and Walmart are worried the deal will eat into their own budding delivery service plans.

Prior to DoorDash and Instacart going public about their merger, competitors already considered the deal a certainty and a threat. But the Justice Department should let the deal go through to ensure that Amazon and Walmart, which were able to consolidate control in their industries when the public-health emergency shut down many of their competitors six years ago, don't get another unfair advantage.

On Nov. 4, days after the deal was announced, Uber Technologies (UBER) CEO Dara Khosrowshahi addressed the merger in an earnings call. On one hand, Khosrowshahi said that Uber, which owns Uber Eats, wasn't that worried about it. He said Uber's grocery and retail business was worth $15 billion annualized and was growing at 40% annually.

But he also bemoaned the usual: The merger would hurt retailers who want choices by eliminating one independent delivery player from the market. Khosrowshahi said merchant partners were expressing concern and wanted to lock in on Uber Eats as the alternative.

"When we talk to our merchant partners, they want choice. They want to develop direct channels. They want plenty of partners, including us and DoorDash and Instacart, to work with," Khosrowshahi said on the call. "This potential deal takes one of those partners off the table, and we have already had reach-outs from our partners, both who are very worried about the potential transaction."

Then, a day later and less than a week after the merger was announced, Uber Eats inked a deal with Amazon delivery. This partnership should serve as evidence to the Justice Department that Amazon (AMZN) is a serious DoorDash (DASH) and Instacart (CART) competitor in the food and grocery delivery space now.

Then there's Walmart.

Walmart (WMT) has made several significant delivery announcements in recent months, including partnerships that put it in more direct competition with DoorDash and Instacart. The company also announced a new offer for deliveries on Nov. 5. This one was straight out of "Star Wars" - a tie-up with Zipline, a drone delivery service.

In September, Walmart partnered on deliveries with Dunkin' and Papa Johns. Walmart started restaurant deliveries through Subway earlier this year, and by August it had expanded its 30-minute-or-less delivery service into 38 cities and towns across the country.

Walmart is not simply delivering groceries it sells in its own stores anymore. It's turning its existing retail distribution network into a broader restaurant and local commerce delivery platform.

DoorDash and InstaCart go public with their plans to merge just before Halloween, and the following week Khosrowshahi is discussing the competitive implications. Shortly after, Uber announces a distribution partnership with Amazon.

That's a remarkable sequence of events in this space over the course of roughly eight weeks. These partnerships indicate how giant online retailers, especially membership platforms like Amazon, can leverage their scale to crown winners and drive out competition.

The competitive landscape for professional delivery service is changing, and the DoorDash-InstaCart merger is a direct result of that trend. It's either join forces, or be taken out.

Amazon and Walmart already control nearly half of the online grocery market, according to eMarketer, a business intelligence firm. The Amazon-Uber Eats partnership could push a greater share of broad food delivery to Amazon, which would also hurt competition.

If regulators are concerned about the combined market power of DoorDash and Instacart, how should they account for Uber Eats gaining access to the Amazon Prime customer base of nearly 200 million in the same week? There's no investigation pending there. The Amazon-Uber Eats agreement is a commercial distribution partnership, not an acquisition. It generally wouldn't trigger the mandatory Hart-Scott-Rodino premerger review process.

Walmart and Amazon want to do what Dash and Instacart are doing. It's clear. Haven't we had enough of these giants benefiting from 2020 public-health policies that saw their smaller competitors forced into lockdowns while they stayed in business like it was just another day?

Mergers need scrutiny. Consumers want choices and don't want to be hoodwinked into the loss of a competitor that drives up prices. For DoorDash and InstaCart users, they would no longer need subscriptions for both services. The companies estimate that would result in more than $100 million in annual savings for their combined consumer base.

Merging, they claim, could also allow the new company to deliver more investments in grocery affordability for consumers. Maybe they are right. But rejecting two pure-play delivery companies in favor of the vertical global juggernauts that are muscling in on their turf would likely sink DoorDash and Instacart share prices. Amazon, Walmart and Uber, meanwhile, will do fine whether these two become one entity or remain separate.

The big guys are getting some free lobbying already.

"Corporate consolidation means higher prices, harsher exploitation, and greater economic inequality for New Yorkers," New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani said in a post on X.

On the other hand, retail associations argue that combining delivery infrastructure and technology can help independent grocers compete against Amazon and Walmart.

"We feel that DoorDash and Instacart coming together helps us continue to provide the best experience for our customers," said George Zoitas, CEO of Westside Market in New York City.

Antitrust policy should protect competition, not necessarily protect competitors from becoming larger. As the DoorDash and InstaCart deal gets reviewed, it's going to be hard to ignore the enormous advantages Amazon and Walmart accumulated during the pandemic, when smaller businesses struggled to survive and the retail giants expanded their reach.

DoorDash and Instacart cannot compete with those companies store for store, warehouse for warehouse or dollar for dollar. Combining their delivery networks may be their best chance to compete at scale. Investors will be rewarded. The other guys won't suffer. Blocking this merger in the name of competition risks for the e-commerce behemoths preserves the market dominance antitrust regulators are supposed to challenge.

Kenneth Rapoza is an analyst for the Coalition for a Prosperous America, which represents U.S. producers and workers. He worked as a Wall Street Journal reporter in Brazil and a BRICS reporter for Forbes.

-Kenneth Rapoza

 

At the request of the copyright holder, you need to log in to view this content

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment