Major US banks revise online banking terms, customers may bear liability for AI agent unauthorized transactions

Deep News11-22 08:52

On November 24, Wells Fargo's new Online Access Agreement will take effect.

Under the newly added terms, if a customer hands over online banking login credentials to a third-party AI agent, or otherwise authorizes it to operate on their behalf, the bank will treat transactions initiated by the agent as authorized by the customer, unless otherwise provided by law or regulation.

Even if the agent misinterprets instructions or exceeds its authority, the agreement assigns the corresponding liability to the customer. When revoking authorization, the customer must keep records and notify the bank. To the extent permitted by law, the customer remains responsible for the agent's operations before the bank is notified.

Citibank also updated its Online User Agreement in November.

If a customer first provides login credentials to a third-party agent and those credentials are subsequently transferred or leaked, operations conducted by others using those credentials will still be deemed authorized by the customer under the agreement.

Liability provisions regarding agent errors and exceeding authority also retain the exception for applicable law providing otherwise.

During roughly the same period, JPMorgan Chase and PNC Bank tightened access permissions.

Starting October 27, JPMorgan Chase prohibited external AI and other third-party tools from using customer credentials to log into online banking. With customer authorization, these tools can still access account data through bank-approved interfaces.

PNC Bank's new agreement, effective December 19, prohibits customers from providing passwords or one-time verification codes to third-party agents, and also prohibits using browser automation, screen scraping, or shared sessions to bypass the bank's access restrictions.

How these provisions apply in transfer disputes will depend on the US Electronic Fund Transfer Act and its implementing rule, Regulation E.

The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's official interpretation states that when a consumer gives account access tools to another person and authorizes them to make transfers, the consumer is generally still responsible for transfers made before the bank is notified to revoke authorization, even if the other person exceeds their authority.

If someone obtains account access tools through fraud or robbery, transfers initiated by them may constitute unauthorized transactions. After receiving a compliant error notice, the bank must still handle it according to the rules.

The official interpretation uses examples of family members and colleagues making transfers on behalf of others. In the agent scenario, banks must also determine what permissions the customer granted, who actually initiated the transfer, and whether the credentials fell into someone else's hands.

On November 16, Federal Reserve Governor Michael Barr said in Milan that some large banks have discovered agents attempting to operate personal accounts, but it is difficult to confirm whether requests are genuine, whether customers consent, and whether operations comply with customer instructions;

He also proposed strengthening identity authentication, verifying customer consent for specific operations, and limiting what operations agents can execute.

In China, the Payment & Clearing Association of China issued the Self-Regulatory Convention on Agent Payment Applications on August 24, requiring that core businesses such as account management, transaction processing, and fund clearing and settlement be carried out by licensed institutions. Member units must verify users' payment intent and specify transaction limits, debit accounts, and validity periods in authorization agreements. Before conducting autonomous agent payments, they must also report to the association.

Some products have first opened up query functions.

For example, China Merchants Bank credit cards have connected with WeChat and Qianwen agents, with the WeChat side providing services such as bill inquiries;

In the US market, Claude's personal finance feature and Gemini's account inquiry function after connecting to Google Wallet also use read-only permissions. Users can authorize tools to view account information, but the tools cannot transfer funds through these functions.

Payments have also been tested in limited scenarios.

When China UnionPay released the Open Protocol Framework for Agent Payments in April, the first batch included 19 domestic and international partners, and completed 5 production system verification transactions. In an airline ticket booking test, users first selected a flight, and the agent then used a linked credit card to complete payment. The feature was only available to whitelisted users at the time.

Wells Fargo's new terms will take effect before Thanksgiving and the "Black Friday" shopping season.

If a customer asks an agent to find a discounted item, but the agent directly places an order and deducts payment, and the customer later disputes it, the bank will need to determine whether the permissions the customer gave the agent included that payment.

Login records can show how the agent entered the account. When it comes to whether a refund is warranted, it still depends on whether there are records proving that the customer consented to the agent spending that money.

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Comments

We need your insight to fill this gap
Leave a comment