Fear of excessive Fed tightening is dominating global commodity markets, with the metals sector caught in an indiscriminate selloff.
Daniel Ghali, head of metals research at Deutsche Bank, warned in a report released on November 18 that the selloff in metals markets such as copper and gold has evolved into a new market regime — capital no longer distinguishes between strong and weak fundamentals, instead indiscriminately liquidating the entire sector. Copper prices collapsed during a historic squeeze, while gold broke below prior support despite strong physical demand, both diverging sharply from supply-demand reality.
Deutsche Bank believes the core driver behind this regime shift is that inflation expectations have fallen substantially, yet hawkish rhetoric from Fed officials has shown no sign of softening. In particular, Fed Governor Waller, even after inflation expectations were repriced, still left room for a 50 basis point rate hike at a single meeting, further intensifying market concerns about over-tightening.
Deutsche Bank noted that a major reversal in metals markets would only be likely if one of three conditions occurs: the Fed shifts to a dovish tone, clear cracks appear in equity or credit markets, or broader financial conditions tighten. Until then, the liquidation process is far from over.
Indiscriminate selling: fundamentals fail, prices decouple from reality
The most striking signal in the Deutsche Bank report is the extreme divergence between commodity prices and supply-demand fundamentals.
Copper market price action is particularly contradictory. China copper cathode premiums surged to about $360 per tonne, near historic highs, indicating that the world's largest consumer market has extremely urgent delivery demand for copper. At the same time, the Shanghai Futures Exchange copper market is facing a historic squeeze, so large that it is not only sufficient to open the import arbitrage window and accelerate LME inventory outflows, but could even pull metal out of CME warehouses. The copper market is seeing an extremely rare combination of tightening spot premiums alongside a sharp drop in spot prices.
Deutsche Bank characterizes this anomaly as direct evidence of "indiscriminate selling." The report notes that commodity forward curves are typically closely tied to fundamentals, and the current extreme divergence between the curve and spot prices confirms that the market mechanism has undergone a fundamental shift — capital is indiscriminately selling all metal assets, including those whose supply is already extremely tight.
Gold: strong physical demand, but financial flows dominate pricing
Gold price action is similarly disconnected from fundamentals, though the underlying logic differs.
The Deutsche Bank report notes that gold's sensitivity to real rates has fallen sharply since 2022, and in theory gold does not necessarily need to come under pressure as real rates rise. However, the current high correlation between gold prices and real rates is rooted, according to Deutsche Bank, in the positioning effects of financial flows.
According to Deutsche Bank's analytical framework, when financial demand (including ETP and CME non-commercial positioning flows) dominates physical demand (including bar and coin and official sector demand), gold's correlation with real rates historically strengthens significantly. The current degree of correlation is only comparable to periods of historic policy surprise shocks, further confirming that the market has entered an over-tightening pricing regime.
From a positioning structure perspective, Deutsche Bank found that CME gold non-commercial long positions are already at historic lows, and after accounting for quant fund leverage and the growth in commodity index AUM over the past decade, the actual underweight is even more pronounced. At the same time, the report also found evidence that discrete speculative shorts are beginning to enter. However, Deutsche Bank also noted that long liquidation is mainly reflected in position size contraction rather than a decline in positioning breadth, and shorts currently still have ample room to continue adding. ETF holdings have also not yet shown systemic redemption signals similar to 2013.
Copper: CTA deleveraging plus recession fears, shorts still have room to add
The evolution of positioning in the copper market reveals another layer of structural pressure behind this selloff.
The Deutsche Bank report shows that before this correction, CME copper market positioning was overall elevated, especially CTA (Commodity Trading Advisor) positions. Driven by high leverage, CTA long positions had previously approached historic extremes. As the selloff unfolded, CTA positions have been substantially unwound, and algorithmic trading positions have generally moved toward neutral, but systematic trend followers still have considerable room to continue increasing shorts.
From the perspective of discrete money managers, current HG copper net long positions have fallen to their lowest level since March 2022, approaching levels seen during the March 2020 COVID shock. LME investment fund net positioning also shows that historically, only during periods when recession fears dominated would positioning remain below current levels for an extended period. LME shorts have also accumulated substantially since mid-October.
Over-tightening fears: trigger mechanism and historical precedent
Deutsche Bank believes the current regime shift is highly similar to the global macro environment around December 2018.
The report notes that the core catalyst for this regime shift is the sharp decline in inflation compensation prices — over the past month, market inflation expectations have undergone substantial repricing, with multiple market-based indicators and economist forecasts showing easing inflation concerns. However, Fed officials' rhetoric remains firmly hawkish and has not adjusted with changes in inflation expectations, triggering concerns that the monetary policy reaction function has changed and the risk of over-tightening has risen. Waller still opening the door to a 50 basis point hike after inflation expectations were repriced has further heightened this concern.
Deutsche Bank believes the most direct path to resolving current market tensions is a softening signal in Fed rhetoric — analogous to the precedent in January 2019 when Powell introduced "patience" language and calmed the excessive tightening turmoil in global markets at that time. The report also notes that current Chair Warsh's stance on forward guidance could delay the emergence of this signal, making market turbulence last longer than the baseline assumption.
If the reversal signal comes from a breakdown in equity markets or financial conditions rather than a proactive dovish shift by the Fed, Deutsche Bank believes the rebound in metals markets would be more dramatic and could reignite the "currency debasement" trade logic linked to dollar weakness and fiscal concerns.
Near-term forecasts face significant downside risk, silver underperforms gold
Deutsche Bank maintains its bullish base case for medium- to long-term gold and copper trends, but emphasizes that near-term forecasts face considerable downside risk.
The report notes that the market's collective resistance only delays rather than cancels gold's recovery path, and cannot resolve the extreme scarcity problem — the latter being the core support for Deutsche Bank's call for a substantial copper price rally — unless over-tightening eventually spreads to economic growth and the macro level.
Silver's continued underperformance relative to gold is consistent with Deutsche Bank's earlier call that the "silver squeeze" rally had peaked, but the decline has exceeded expectations. Deutsche Bank also warns that if over-tightening fears continue to build and ultimately trigger a recession, copper supply shortage expectations could be offset in more extreme scenarios. Additionally, the U.S. chip export restriction issue could reignite geopolitical risk at the renewal juncture of the Busan armistice agreement, which is inextricably linked to the critical minerals issue.
Comments